Terms of Sale

Her parents can’t live
in their house anymore.
The stairs, the driveway 
coated with snow, 
the hill,
her mom’s hip and dad’s knees,
their diminishing
pensions.

So they decide to sell.
Empty the house,
clean and paint it 
so it looks anonymous and bright.

They excise all things personal
except the piano. 
Her great-aunt’s piano.

Her great-aunt loved music;
everyone in her family loves music.
Her brother plays metal guitar; her uncles, banjo; her dad guiro when
the spirit moves him.

All of us have crowded around those keys.

But her parents won’t have space 
in the apartment they’ll move to after the sale. 
It is stairless,
with a metal bar to grip in the shower and
a sidewalk they won’t have to shovel.

So her parents offer the piano 
to the buyers they find for the house.
The buyers say yes, they like the look:
the piano is large, old and elegant. 
Mahogany.

Only later, a few days before the sale,
the day the government changes
the buyers also change their minds.
Tell her parents to get rid of it. 

Her father tries to sell or give it away.
To music schools and churches,
acquaintances and friendly, anonymous accounts online. 
He promises to borrow a truck 
to deliver it.

A few people call and say they’re interested
but then they change their minds too.
The buyers of the house want it gone.

Her parents realize they’ll have to throw it away. A piano
that is nearly a hundred years old, that supposedly
survived the war.

Her father is resourceful. He says maybe he can 
peel off the ivory keys and sell them.
Her mother puts her fists in her ears. 

At the dual-language school where her cousin works,
men in black vests with white print try to break down the door,
try to find children to disappear. 
Afterwards, she silences her son 
when he speaks Spanish in the street.

Her father realizes he must use a sledgehammer 
to break the piano, 
to turn it into timber,
into disposable bits.
But the hammer slips from his hands.
He cannot destroy it, cannot
tear its keys with pliers,
cannot pull them like teeth.

He has a friend who is new to this country,
who watched
his own country crumble
with a few strokes of a pen.
He tells her father he can stomach it,
that you can stomach anything if you have enough
need.
Says once a thing is in pieces,
it gets easier to forget
what was and wasn’t there.

Relocation

When the woman from Housing knocked, I figured she wanted to sell me pest control. Or solar panels. Or Jesus. I can always tell by the clipboard.

“Ma’am,” she said—ma’am, like I was about to scold someone for leaving a wet towel on the floor—“we’re conducting an occupancy check.”

A man stood behind her, his shirt the color of mop water, the washed-out gray government workers think looks friendly. He held a tablet, my address glowing at the top, my name almost right, off by one letter.

Arguing over spelling never won anyone peace.

I let them in.

They went room to room, tapping walls and photographing outlets as if the house might confess something. The woman trailed a finger along the banister. “You’ve kept it up nicely,” she said. “Mr. Elias will be pleased.”

“Who’s Mr. Elias?”

“The tenant on record.”

After they left, the air smelled like melting plastic. I opened drawers, found my pinking shears, old twist ties, that bent spoon I never threw out. Everything looked fine, I guess, but it felt wrong, like the place had been rebuilt backward, with left where right should be, right where left belonged.

On the fridge, I found a Post-it note with my handwriting. It read: appointment confirmed. The loops were too loose for my cursive, so maybe I’d clicked some online I agree form inadvertently. The government changed files, after all. Maybe it now changed people, too.

That night, I dreamed the house split, quiet as a bone cracking in winter. In the morning, the kitchen reeked of melted plastic again. My chipped blue mug was nowhere to be found. A tin cup sat there instead, stamped Property of the Department of Residence Affairs.

By noon, I heard a key turn in the lock, smooth as butter, and a man rolled a suitcase through the front door. “Miss Carrie?” he asked, which isn’t even close to my name.

“I think you’ve got the wrong house,” I said.

He smiled like a social worker. “I’ve got the lease.” He handed me a laminated card that read 412 Ash Street. My address. The owner was listed as The State. Then he went up the stairs and moved into the guest room.

I spent days on hold with numbers that played a tinny flute tone on repeat. My lawyer—if you can call someone you pay in pizza a lawyer—told me the system showed I’d been relocated six months back. “They’ve got receipts,” he said.

“I never moved.”

“Then you’ll need proof you exist.”

So I sent the department photos of myself in the house—blowing out candles, opening presents under the Christmas tree, petting Minnie, my cat, as she curled on the radiator like a warm loaf. They wrote back: metadata unverifiable; possibly fabricated.

A week later, Minnie vanished. Not a single white hair left on the sofa.

Mr. Elias mostly stayed in his room. I heard him typing, fast, steady, like the house had given him orders. Once I asked, “Why are you here?”

“Everyone needs somewhere to live,” he said.

“This house is mine.”

He smiled, the kind that said you don’t know yet. “Then why does your name keep disappearing?”

Days blurred. Mail arrived for the Current Resident. None for me. My bank account locked itself. At City Hall, the clerk peered over her screen. “You’re listed as temporarily reassigned.”

“I’m right here.”

She glanced at the line of people behind me. “Are you sure?”

Outside, all the front doors on my block had grown small black eyes that blinked red in the dusk.

***

Mr. Elias invited me to dinner. He made rice and beans heavy on the cumin. “No reason we can’t be neighborly,” he said, telling me how he’d lived in the house before redevelopment. “They said the block was unsafe. Moved us out. When they rebuilt, my number came up again.”

Behind him, a pale rectangle marked the wallpaper where my grandmother’s clock had once hung.

“My mother was born in this house,” I said.

He nodded. “Maybe it’s yours in memory, but documents say otherwise.”

After that, I took to the porch. The air turned mean with cold, but it was still free. I watched the streetlights do their little dying act every night—blink, gone, blink, gone. New fences went up, strange cars parked and disappeared, people argued behind closed doors. A drone would pass overhead, dragging its yellow light from yard to yard. Sometimes it paused above me, gave me the once-over like a clerk scanning produce.

After a while, I stopped picking up when Housing called. The woman’s messages always began, We’d like to help you transition.

Transition to where? The moon?

***

The house forgot me. The thermostat wouldn’t listen. The lock refused my key. The floorboards went silent under my feet.

One sleepless night, I opened my laptop and searched real estate listings just to torture myself. There it was. My house. Two bedrooms. Safe neighborhood. Surveillance included. In one photo, a woman who looked just like me stood by the porch light, waving.

I gave up. I packed a coat, a toothbrush, a photograph of my family on a dock in a lake, all of us smiling in the hard sun. Then I walked through each room, memorizing each detail. In the entryway, I leaned into the wainscoting and whispered my name. The wood was pliable. I’d painted that wall a deep teal with my mother when I was twelve. “Color,” she said, “can change your life.”

At the door, Mr. Elias waited, arms crossed tight.

“Will you take care of this house?” I asked.

“I’ll keep it safe,” he said.

I stepped outside and eased the door shut. Snow drifted heavy, steady as static. When I reached the corner, the street was blank. I looked back, but my footprints were already gone.

Somebody Should Do Something

We woke to no running water. Not even a drop fell from our showerheads that morning. The little water we did have drizzled from the faucets. We assumed myopically this was an issue specific to our home, that we would have to call a plumber from our desks at work. It was only on our commute that we realized what had happened. A water main had burst and flooded Tremont Square. Police had closed the road. Men in neon vests and hard hats milled about the ankle-high water. Tremont Square was by the adult language school, in a part of town where most of the tenants were students—renters, not owners. The flooded street ran in front of the liquor store. Across the street, the YMCA. On the town’s flagpole, the old, tattered, thin and translucent American flag snapped. It was fortunate for us because we lived at the top of the hill about a mile away. We didn’t have to worry about our home flooding; we were relieved we wouldn’t need to pay a plumber after all. 

When we came home that night, the men in vests were still working and the water had not returned. We were understandably upset. We had grown accustomed to water always springing from our taps, our lights never failing, our supermarkets always being stocked. These conveniences were our birthright. On the news, they explained that the water break had created a small sinkhole, and a young man had (presumably) died that morning when the ground underneath him suddenly fell away. The station had obtained footage of the incident, which, they warned, might not be suitable for young children and the sensitive. 

The moment had been captured on the liquor store’s security camera. The time stamp in the bottom right hand corner read 5:47 a.m. The footage was gray and grainy. A dark figure shuffled down the sidewalk across the empty street. The earth opened up. It was almost grotesque, how quickly the man could go from being there to not being there. Even when the station slowed the video down frame by frame, it was almost impossible to process. 

More details about the missing man would come out over the following days. He had immigrated from Syria on a temporary visa, he was studying English at the language school, and that morning he had been on his way to the Washington Street Dunkin’ Donuts for his 6 a.m. shift. Some people online were very alarmed. Others posted jokes, such as the clip paired with the caption: “Me when I get overstimulated at the party.” The Christians claimed that this was a sign of Armageddon, that soon, as the Bible predicted, “the heavens will disappear with a roar.” On our own community webpage, faceless usernames confessed that while they didn’t necessarily want anyone to die, they wouldn’t mind there being less foreigners in the neighborhood. 

We gave fifty dollars to the victim’s family’s GoFundMe. It wasn’t immediately obvious what else we could do.  

In the meantime, they had diverted water from another main; our house was back to normal. We trusted the infrastructure, trusted that the competent people we had elected would fix the sinkhole problem. After all, we paid taxes for precisely this reason. So, we avoided that part of the neighborhood, drove around the commotion on our way to work, adding so much as five to ten minutes to our morning commute.  

But the sinkhole kept expanding. The perplexed city officials assured us that they were attempting every measure and tactic to resolve the problem. Yet every day there was a new story of someone who had strayed too close to the sinkhole and had plummeted into its earthy maw. At first, it was mostly other students from the language school, but then we started hearing stories of other homeowners, people that we knew from softball leagues and the farmers’ market, vanishing into the hole as well. Soon businesses shuttered, either because their building or all of their minimum-wage workers had vanished. 

At dinner parties, inevitably someone would announce, exasperated, “Somebody should do something about that sinkhole! This is no way to live,” and we’d all nod our heads in solemn agreement.

As the hole chewed closer and closer toward us, shutting down more and more roads, we assured ourselves that if it was really a problem, then people—people more capable, more educated than us—would surely say something. We weren’t engineers. We weren’t public servants. What were we supposed to do? We had debts to pay, cars to wash, meals to cook, parent-teacher conferences to attend, family to pick up from the airport. 

The population of our town had rapidly declined. When we went for walks around the surviving half of the neighborhood, there was no longer the sense that we were moving through a town, or a community, or even a civilized country, but rather a raw, sinister feeling that we were exploring the ruins of something. 

Last week, the hole began ascending our street. We lost our water again, then the power. We could have left this place, once, but there was no longer a way off of our big hill. For supplies, we had only the reserves in our cupboards, the gallons of water we bought in bulk for such emergencies. 

Sitting on the balcony last night, we huddled underneath our blankets and stirred the last of our hot chocolate powder into bottled water boiled over a fire. The sky seemed so low that we thought our heads might scrape against it. If we looked out over the railing, we could stare down directly into the heart of the sinkhole. We had never seen it from up close before. Our voices echoed down the pitch-black cavity. And it was only then, when it was right outside our doorstep, that we realized how wrong we had been to assume that the hole must have a bottom.

“A House Divided” Finalists

Our final challenge of the year, “A House Divided,” asked for writing that explored home, displacement, and what the shape of shelter looks like today. We’re excited to announce our finalists, whose works reveal the pain of fractured family histories, the nature of erasure, and detachment from danger until it arrives on one’s doorstep. Please join us in congratulating our winners! We are eager to publish their pieces at the end of December. 

First place

“Terms of Sale” by M. Colón-Margolies

Second place

“Relocation” by Cate McGowan

Third place

“Somebody Should Do Something” by David Brinson

Prepare for landing—these winning pieces will publish at the end of December. Can’t wait? Read the winners from last month’s challenge here.

“A House Divided” Shortlist

We’re pleased to announce the shortlist from our final challenge of the year. This list recognizes the poems, stories, and essays that stopped us and made us reflect on shelter, resistance, resilience, and hope. Join us in celebrating these writers, and stay tuned for the finalists next week! 

“The Statue in the Chapel” by Sunny Chung

“Holy Nights” by Jomil Ebro

“The Shovel Shirt” by Aishatu Ado

“Mother, I” by Nikola Marshal

“Clean Hands” by Michelle Oxford

“Where I Have a Home” by Jonathan Ukah

“The Gift” by Erin Winseman

Next challenge launches January 1!

X