As someone trying to make their way as a writer, I’ve spent a lot of time looking for what other writers have said about their journeys and perspectives on writing. Of all the tips I’ve found, one of my favorites is an anecdote from Alan Moore.
You’ve likely heard his name in relation to his 1986 medium-redefining graphic novel Watchmen, but he’s continued writing up to the present day with projects like the urban fantasy series Long London and the experimental novel Jerusalem. He’s been asked to give writing tips numerous times, and the one that stands out to me is insightful, but not immediately obvious:
You need to read terrible books.
On his BBC Maestro series on becoming a writer, Moore explained that bad books “can be more inspiring than the good books.” Or, as he puts it, they make you think: “Jesus Christ, I could write this s***.”
The value of that response is that it invites you to ask yourself why you feel that way. “Why did that offend me so much?” Moore asks. “Yeah, analyze that, What spoiled the story for you?” By learning what not to do, you can avoid it in your own writing.
“Bad” writing then, is disappointing writing. (I’m not going to pretend that I can provide an objective answer to what “bad” or “good” writing is.) When you read something disappointing and think, “I could write this,” you have an idea for how to improve what you just read. Moore’s advice is to take that disappointment and use it as fuel to put pen to paper. By going over these “bad” works with a critical eye, you can find opportunities to identify where your own writing falls short and where you’ll want to take your writing going forward.
Here are some ways that writing can be disappointing and what to look out for as a reader and a writer:
Dialogue (Why would you talk like that?)
Dialogue needs to tell the reader either about the story or who the characters are, but if your characters spend the entire story expositing, they stop feeling like people and read as tools to move the story along. It draws attention to the artifice, that everything that’s happening is because an author is making it happen. Dialogue is an opportunity to consider a character’s voice and internality. Who is this character? How would they talk?
When you notice dialogue that feels off, stop and think about how you would rewrite it. One easy trap to fall into is having characters tell each other things they should already know for the sake of exposition. When you notice this, capture it, and recall it when writing your own dialogue: What would these characters not need to say to each other?
Characterization (Why are they acting like that?)
How a character is presented throughout a story is a major factor in that story coming together for a reader. Readers expect a character to have a consistent internal logic to how they act so we have a grasp on them as a person. If the story shows them breaking from how they were presented earlier, the reader is going to wonder what’s going on. If it’s never addressed, it will take the reader out of the story.
Even if a character is consistent, they can fail to read as a person and instead as a tool to make the story happen—or as a proxy for the author to preach through. These characters feel off because they don’t feel real, but in figuring out why, you could come up with a compelling character.
Alan Moore has an example of this in Watchmen: the character Rorschach was inspired by the comic characters The Question and Mr. A, both of whom were infamous in the comics fandom Moore grew up in. These characters were vessels for their creator to proselytize his conservative political positions. Moore took these characters as a jumping-off point for Rorschach, a character who displays a similar level of moral absolution but is framed as a pariah among his former peers and is given a backstory to contextualize his extreme positions.
Moore took an inherently unrealistic character and asked, “What would make a person like this?” Then, he came back with a more compelling story.
Plot holes (Wait, what just happened?)
I struggle to think of a mark of “bad writing” that disappoints the reader as much as a plot hole.
A plot hole is when a part of the story doesn’t logically fit with the rest of it, such as a character disappearing from the story with no explanation, or a character knowing something they shouldn’t that the reader doesn’t see them learn. Like with poor dialogue and characterization, it draws attention to the fact that the events on the page are constructed—and, with a plot hole, the construction was rushed or sloppy.
Plot holes are opportunities to peek inside that construction and see what’s missing. What scene or information isn’t there that would make the plot make sense? If more drastic reordering of the plot is needed, how would you go about that? You can get as radical as you want—the saying is, “you can’t fix what isn’t broken,” but this sure is broken. So, take a look inside the gears.
Tone (What…is even going on?)
Problems with tone are similar to plot holes, only instead of affecting the plot, they affect the story in a more abstract way.
Imagine you’re writing a dark and gritty crime story where your protagonist is a P.I. tracking down a murderer. The story’s climax is a chase between them, and the murderer is attempting to lose the P.I. in winding back alleys littered with refuse. It ends when the murderer slips on a banana peel, falls on his back, and is caught.
There isn’t a plot hole here. All the story elements have been properly established. But would you expect that ending based on everything else I told you about this story? I’m guessing not.
When plotting out a story, it’s important to not just consider the logic of how the events come together, but also how the events feel next to each other. The banana peel would be a bad climax because it’s suddenly introducing slapstick comedy into our noir thriller story. A revision would find a new climax that’s more tonally consistent with the rest of the story.
This isn’t to say that your story should be uniform, entirely grim or cheery or haunting, but that you should have a grasp of the tonal range you want your story to inhabit.
What makes a piece of art “bad” or disappointing is always going to be subjective to each reader. If you find a creative choice that bugs or offends you in a story, remember that the writer thought it was a good choice. The person who made it was a human being with subjective taste, just like you. If they got their writing to print, with all of the issues you have with it, then you can do the same. Moore described this realization as “liberating.” I find it hard to disagree.
Learn about how to get feedback on your writing (plus a list of publications that offer it), and download our free Lit Mag Submission Kit to polish up your cover letter and bio.